Soft Centers – Creams, Peanut Butter Cups & Jellies
At Mueller Chocolate Co., our Soft Centers Collection celebrates chocolates with smooth, creamy, and fruit-filled centers wrapped in rich chocolate. Handmade and shipped fresh, these confections are customer favorites for gifting and everyday indulgence, especially for those who don't want a cruncy or hard center. These chocolates can be smushed between your fingers; they are so soft.
Our lineup includes timeless chocolate creams — silky buttercream centers coated in milk or dark chocolate. These are traditional candy box staples that never go out of style. We also craft peanut butter cups, pairing smooth peanut butter with a chocolate shell, as well as buckeyes, a regional favorite with rich peanut butter partially dipped in chocolate for the perfect bite.
For fruit lovers, our raspberry jellies offer a burst of tart sweetness, perfectly complemented by the smoothness of milk or dark chocolate. Each piece offers a distinct soft center, but all deliver the same freshness and quality that have made Mueller Chocolate Co. a Philadelphia favorite for generations.
These chocolates are available in 24-piece gift boxes, making them a thoughtful present for birthdays, holidays, or thank-you gifts. They're also a popular choice to keep at home, ready to enjoy whenever you want a little indulgence.
Unlike mass-produced boxed chocolates, our soft center chocolates are made in small batches to ensure flavor, texture, and freshness. Whether you're craving buttercreams, peanut butter cups, buckeyes, or raspberry jellies, our collection delivers the perfect balance of smooth centers and rich chocolate coatings.
Explore the Soft Centers Collection today and discover why these classics remain some of the most beloved chocolates we make..
