New product Chocolate Covered Nutter Butters are now available here!  

  • Compare Products
  • Sign In
  • Create an Account
Search
Products
Advanced Search
My Cart
Toggle Nav
Menu
Account

Chocolate

Muellers Chocolate is rich and creamy and handmade in small batches.

160 Items

Set Descending Direction
  1. Milk and Dark Sea Salt Caramel | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Sea Salt Caramels Mixed Milk and Dark 24 Piece Gift Box

    $25.95
  2. Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramels | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Dark Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel 24 Piece Gift box

    $25.95
  3. Milk Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel Gift box | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Milk Chocolate Sea Salt Caramel 24 Piece Gift Box

    $25.95
  4. White Chocolate Cookies and Cream Bark | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    White Chocolate Cookies and Cream Bark 1 Lb Box

    $24.95
  5. M&M Milk Chocolate Bark | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    M & M Bark

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $24.95
  6. Spooky Halloween Chocolate Kitty | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Spooky Halloween Chocolate Kitty

    $15.00
  7. Solid Chocolate Skull - | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Chocolate Skull

    $19.95
  8. Chocolate Scarecrow pop

    Milk Chocolate Scarecrow Pop - Pack of 6

    $24.00
  9. Dr.Chockenstein Chocolate Bar | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Dr.Chockenstein® Dark Chocolate Chocolate Bar

    $4.95
  10. Assorted Vanilla Butter Creams | Mueller Chocolate co.

    Assorted Vanilla Butter Creams 24 Piece Gift Box

    $24.95
  11. Dark Chocolate Almond Bark | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Dark Chocolate Almond Bark

    $28.95
  12. Gourmet Milk Chocolate Covered Pretzels | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Gourmet Milk Chocolate Covered Pretzels

    Rating:
    100%
    4  Reviews
    $24.95
  13. Dark Chocolate Pecan Turtles | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Dark Chocolate Pecan Turtles

    Rating:
    100%
    3  Reviews
    $28.95
  14. Gourmet Dark Chocolate Almond Clusters | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet Dark Chocolate Almond Clusters

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $28.95
  15. Dark chocolate white seed nonpareils | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Dark Chocolate Nonpareils with White Seeds

    $24.95
  16. Dark Vanilla Butter Creams Box | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Dark Vanilla Butter Creams Box 24 Piece Gift Box

    $24.95
  17. Gourmet Milk Chocolate Almond Bark | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Milk Chocolate Almond Bark

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $28.95
  18. Gourmet Dark Chocolate Covered Pretzels | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet Dark Chocolate Covered Pretzels

    Rating:
    100%
    2  Reviews
    $24.95
  19. Milk Chocolate Pecan Turtles | Mueller Chocolate co.

    Milk Chocolate Pecan Turtles

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $28.95
  20. Gourmet Milk Chocolate Almond Clusters | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet Milk Chocolate Almond Clusters

    $28.95
  21. Assorted Chocolates Milk Chocolate

    Assorted Chocolates Milk Chocolate

    $24.95
  22. Milk Chocolate Nonpareils with White Seeds | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Milk Chocolate Nonpareils with White Seeds

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $24.95
  23. Milk Chocolate Molasses Sponge

    Milk Chocolate Molasses Sponge

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $24.95
  24. Sea Salt Dark Chocolate Almond Bark | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Sea Salt Dark Chocolate Almond Bark

    $28.95
  25. Gourmet White Chocolate Covered Pretzels | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet White Chocolate Covered Pretzels

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $24.95
  26. Dark Chocolate Orange Peel

    Dark Chocolate Glazed Orange Peel

    $28.95
  27. Dark Chocolate Cashew Turtles | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Dark Chocolate Cashew Turtles

    Rating:
    100%
    2  Reviews
    $28.95
  28. Gourmet Milk Chocolate Cashew Clusters | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet Milk Chocolate Cashew Clusters

    $28.95
  29. Milk Chocolate Nonpareils with Seasonal Seeds | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Milk Chocolate Nonpareils with Seasonal Seeds

    $24.95
  30. Dark Chocolate Molasses Sponge

    Dark Chocolate Molasses Sponge

    $24.95
  31. Peanut Butter Buckeyes | Mueller Chocolate co.

    Peanut Butter Buckeye 24 Piece Box

    $24.95
  32. Peanut Butter Chocolate Covered Pretzels

    Peanut Butter Chocolate Covered Pretzels

    $24.95
  33. Milk Chocolate Cashew Turtles | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Milk Chocolate Cashew Turtles

    Rating:
    80%
    1  Review
    $28.95
  34. Gourmet Dark Chocolate Cashew Clusters | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet Dark Chocolate Cashew Clusters

    $28.95
  35. Assorted Chocolates Dark Chocolate | Mueller Chocolate co.

    Assorted Chocolates Dark Chocolate

    Rating:
    100%
    2  Reviews
    $24.95
  36. Dark Chocolate Nonpareils with Seasonal Seeds | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Dark Chocolate Nonpareils with Seasonal Seeds

    $24.95
  37. Reeses Pieces Bark | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Reeses Pieces Bark

    $24.95
  38. Gourmet Milk Chocolate Coconut Clusters | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet Milk Chocolate Coconut Clusters

    $28.95
  39. Gourmet Half-Dipped Chocolate Pretzels Peanut butter and Milk Chocolate

    Gourmet Half-Dipped Peanut Butter and Milk Chocolate Pretzels

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $24.95
  40. Milk Chocolate Butter Creams | Mueller Chocolate co.

    Milk Chocolate Butter Creams Box 24pc

    $24.95
  41. Gourmet Dark Chocolate Coconut Clusters | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet Dark Chocolate Coconut Clusters

    $28.95
  42. Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate Half-Dipped Pretzels | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Peanut Butter Dark Chocolate Half-Dipped Pretzels

    $24.95
  43. Sugar Free Dark Chocolate Almond Bark

    Sugar Free Dark Chocolate Almond Bark

    $33.95
  44. Gourmet Dark Chocolate Macadamia Clusters | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet Dark Chocolate Macadamia Clusters

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $28.95
  45. Milk Chocolate Covered Potato Chips | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Milk Chocolate Covered Potato Chips

    $33.95
  46. Half-Dipped White & Milk Chocolate Pretzels | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Half-Dipped White & Milk Chocolate Pretzels

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $24.95
  47. Half-Dipped White & Dark Chocolate Pretzels | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Half-Dipped White & Dark Chocolate Pretzels

    $24.95
  48. Milk and Dark Chocolate Raspberry Jellies | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Milk and Dark Combo Raspberry Jellies

    $25.95
  49. Sugar Free Milk Chocolate Almond Bark | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Sugar Free Milk Chocolate Almond Bark

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $33.95
  50. Dark Chocolate Anatomically Correct Heart | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Dark Chocolate Anatomically Correct Heart

    $19.95
  51. Gourmet Milk Chocolate Macadamia Clusters | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet Milk Chocolate Macadamia Clusters

    $28.95
  52. Dark Chocolate Covered Potato Chips

    Dark Chocolate Covered Potato Chips

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $33.95
  53. Dark Chocolate Nutter Butter | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Milk Chocolate Nutter Butter

    $24.95
  54. Dark Chocolate Raspberry Jellies

    Dark Chocolate Raspberry Jellies

    $25.95
  55. Dark chocolate aspirin | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Dark Chocolate Aspirin

    $10.95
  56. Milk Chocolate Peanut Clusters | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet Milk Chocolate Peanut Clusters

    $28.95
  57. Assorted Chocolate Covered Pretzels | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Assorted Chocolate Covered Pretzels

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $24.95
  58. Dark Chocolate Nutter Butter | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Dark Chocolate Nutter Butter

    $24.95
  59. Milk Chocolate Raspberry Jellies

    Milk Chocolate Raspberry Jellies

    $25.95
  60. Gourmet Dark Chocolate Peanut Clusters | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet Dark Chocolate Peanut Clusters

    $28.95
  61. Dark chocolate brains| Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Dark Chocolate Brain

    $19.95
  62. Milk Chocolate Covered Mini Pretzels | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Milk Chocolate Covered Mini Pretzels

    $24.95
  63. Milk Chocolate Animal Crackers | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Milk Chocolate Animal Crackers 1/2 lb

    $12.95
  64. Dark Chocolate Covered Mini Pretzels | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Dark Chocolate Covered Mini Pretzels

    $24.95
  65. Dark Chocolate Pecan Clusters | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet Dark Chocolate Pecan Clusters

    $28.95
  66. Gourmet dark chocolate buds | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Dark Chocolate Buds

    $24.95
  67. Milk & Dark Chocolate Covered Mini Pretzels | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Milk & Dark Chocolate Covered Mini Pretzels

    $24.95
  68. Dark Chocolate Butter Creams | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Dark Chocolate Butter Creams Box 24pc

    $24.95
  69. Milk Chocolate Aspirin | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Milk Chocolate Aspirin

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $10.95
  70. Gourmet Milk Chocolate Pecan Clusters | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet Milk Chocolate Pecan Clusters

    $28.95
  71. Dark Chocolate Caramel Truffles | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Dark Chocolate Caramel Truffles 24 Piece Gift Box

    $28.95
  72. Sugar Free Chocolate Pretzels Milk Chocolate

    Sugar Free Chocolate Pretzels Milk Chocolate

    $33.95
  73. Gourmet Dark Chocolate Raisin Clusters | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet Dark Chocolate Raisin Clusters

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $28.95
  74. Milk Chocolate Brain

    Milk Chocolate Brain

    $19.95
  75. White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups 1lb

    White Chocolate Peanut Butter Cups 1lb

    $24.95
  76. Sugar Free Chocolate Pretzels Dark Chocolate

    Sugar Free Chocolate Pretzels Dark Chocolate

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $33.95
  77. Gourmet Milk Chocolate Raisin Clusters | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Gourmet Milk Chocolate Raisin Clusters

    $28.95
  78. Gourmet milk chocolate buds | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Milk Chocolate Buds

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $24.95
  79. Philadelphia Eagles Nonpareils | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Philadelphia Eagles Nonpareils Milk Chocolate

    $24.95
  80. Sea Salt Caramel Dark Chocolate Covered Pretzels (6)

    Sea Salt Caramel Dark Chocolate Covered Pretzels (6)

    $25.00
  81. Sugar Free Almond Butter Crunch

    Sugar Free Almond Butter Crunch

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $29.95
    Out of stock
  82. Milk Chocolate Caramel Truffles | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Milk Chocolate Caramel Truffles 24 Piece Gift Box

    $28.95
  83. Delight in the Decadence of Mueller's Dark Chocolate Coconut Truffles - Box of 24

    Dark Chocolate Coconut Truffles 24 Piece Gift Box

    $28.95
  84. Sugar Free Clusters Raisin Milk Chocolate

    Sugar Free Clusters Raisin Milk Chocolate

    $33.95
  85. Sea Salt Caramel & Milk Chocolate Covered Pretzels | Mueller Chocolate co

    Sea Salt Caramel & Milk Chocolate Covered Pretzels (12)

    $49.00
  86. Dark Chocolate Cordial Cherries

    Dark Chocolate Cordial Cherries 24 Piece Gift Box

    $24.95
  87. Sugar Free Clusters Raisin Dark Chocolate

    Sugar Free Clusters Raisin Dark Chocolate

    $33.95
  88. Sea Salt Caramel Dark Chocolate Covered Pretzels | Mueller Chocolate Co

    Sea Salt Caramel & Dark Chocolate Covered Pretzels (12)

    $49.00
  89. Milk Chocolate Coconut Truffles | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Milk Chocolate Coconut Truffles 24 Piece Gift Box

    $28.95
  90. Dark Chocolate Covered Caramels Box 24pc

    Dark Chocolate Covered Caramels Box 24pc

    $21.95
  91. Sugar Free Clusters Pecan Dark Chocolate

    Sugar Free Clusters Pecan Dark Chocolate

    $33.95
  92. Sea Salt Caramel & Milk Chocolate Covered Pretzels (12)

    Sea Salt Caramel & Milk Chocolate Covered Pretzels (12)

    $49.00
  93. Milk Chocolate Cordial Cherry Gift Box

    Milk Chocolate Cordial Cherry Gift Box 24 Piece Gift Box

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $24.95
  94. Dark Chocolate Covered English Toffee

    Dark Chocolate Covered English Toffee 24 piece box

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $24.95
  95. Sugar Free Clusters Pecan Milk Chocolate

    Sugar Free Clusters Pecan Milk Chocolate

    $33.95
  96. Sugar Free Clusters Peanut Dark Chocolate

    Sugar Free Clusters Peanut Dark Chocolate

    $33.95
  97. Milk Chocolate Covered Apricots | Mueller Chocolate co

    Milk Chocolate Covered Apricots

    Rating:
    100%
    4  Reviews
    $32.95
  98. Dark Chocolate Covered Grahams | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Dark Chocolate Covered Grahams

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $24.95
  99. Sea Salt Caramel Milk Chocolate Mini Pretzels | Mueller Chocolate Co.

    Sea Salt Caramel Milk Chocolate Mini Pretzels

    Rating:
    100%
    1  Review
    $28.95
  100. Milk Chocolate Covered Caramels Box 24pc

    Milk Chocolate Covered Caramels Box 24pc

    $21.95
Page
per page
Filter
Shop By
Shopping Options