Easter wouldn’t be complete without the tradition of chocolate eggs. Whether you’re planning baskets for the kids, hosting brunch, or sending thoughtful gifts to loved ones across the country, our handmade Easter chocolates bring sweetness and nostalgia to every celebration.
At Mueller Chocolate Co., we’ve been crafting our chocolates by hand in Philadelphia since the 1980s — each one made with the same care and quality that has made us a local favorite for generations. This year, our Easter collection celebrates the classics: buttercream, peanut butter, and coconut cream. These are the best Easter eggs for anyone who loves chocolate with a bit of touch of heritage.
Buttercream Easter Eggs – A Melt-in-Your-Mouth Classic
There’s something timeless about buttercream. Soft, smooth, and rich, our milk chocolate buttercream Easter eggs and dark chocolate buttercream Easter eggs are filled with creamy vanilla centers that melt the moment you take a bite.
Each one is hand-dipped in chocolate, giving that perfect balance of texture — a crisp chocolate shell over a luxuriously soft inside. Buttercreams have been a fan favorite for decades, and they continue to be a top choice for Easter gifting.
They’re the kind of treat that makes people close their eyes after the first bite. Perfect for sharing, or for keeping all to yourself (no judgment here).
Perfect for:
- Grandparents who love classic sweets
- Friends who appreciate old-fashioned chocolate craftsmanship
- Anyone who enjoys a smooth, creamy center that melts away
Peanut Butter Easter Eggs – The Perfect Pairing
Few combinations are more beloved than peanut butter and chocolate. Our milk chocolate peanut butter Easter eggs and dark chocolate peanut butter Easter eggs take that timeless pairing and make it even more irresistible.
Each egg is made with smooth, creamy peanut butter and coated in a thick layer of milk or dark chocolate for a sweet-and-peanut-butter bite that’s completely craveable. They’re soft without being sticky, rich without being too heavy, and absolutely perfect for Easter baskets.
If you’re looking for a treat that both kids and adults can’t get enough of, these peanut butter eggs are a must. They also make thoughtful gifts for teachers, coworkers, or anyone you’d like to surprise with something a little extra special.
Perfect for:
- Peanut butter lovers of all ages
- Kids’ Easter baskets and classroom gifts
- Chocolate fans who want something nostalgic but rich
Coconut Cream Easter Eggs – Light, Sweet, and Spring-Ready
For something lighter but still indulgent, our milk chocolate coconut cream Easter eggs and dark chocolate coconut cream Easter eggs deliver a tropical sweetness that feels like spring in every bite.
The creamy coconut center is whipped to the perfect texture — smooth, slightly chewy, and perfectly balanced by the chocolate shell. These eggs are especially loved by those who enjoy the contrast of rich chocolate with bright, refreshing flavors.
Coconut cream eggs have quietly become one of our most gifted items during Easter because they’re unique, flavorful, and beautifully made.
Perfect for:
- Coconut and dark chocolate lovers
- Easter brunch dessert trays
- Gifts for anyone who enjoys light, spring-inspired flavors
Fun Ways to Celebrate with Chocolate Easter Eggs
Once you’ve picked your favorite flavors, there are countless ways to enjoy them. Here are a few festive ideas to make your Easter even sweeter:
- Build the perfect Easter basket: Mix and match buttercream, peanut butter, and coconut eggs for a personalized touch.
- Hide them for a grown-up egg hunt: Chocolate prizes make Easter just as fun for adults.
- Send sweet surprises: Use our multiship option at checkout to send Easter eggs to multiple friends and family members with one order.
- Host a chocolate tasting: Line up each flavor — buttercream, peanut butter, and coconut — and let everyone choose their favorite.
- Give back: Donate chocolate eggs to a local church, school, or community center.
Why Mueller Chocolate Co. Makes the Best Easter Candy
At Mueller Chocolate Co., our chocolatiers have been handcrafting chocolates in Philadelphia for over 40 years. Every piece is made in small batches, using the finest ingredients and the same attention to detail that started it all back in the 1980s.
We make our chocolates fresh every weekday — no mass production, no shortcuts. Each Easter Egg is created by hand with care and heritage in mind. It’s what makes our chocolates taste as good as they look.
And while our Easter eggs are a seasonal favorite, we’re proud to offer so much more. If you love exploring new flavors, try our chocolate covered pretzels, sea salt caramels, nonpareils, and pecan turtles. You can even read our blog Milk or Dark? The Best Chocolate Pecan Turtles Debate to see which flavor might be your next favorite.
Easter Shipping Made Simple
Whether you’re near or far, sending Easter chocolate from Mueller is easy.
We offer nationwide shipping anywhere in the U.S., so your loved ones can enjoy our handmade Easter eggs no matter where they live. From Philadelphia to California, we pack every order with care to ensure your chocolates arrive in perfect condition.
Need to send multiple gifts? Our multiship checkout option makes it effortless — you can send Easter chocolates to several addresses in one order. It’s the easiest way to make everyone’s holiday a little sweeter.
Celebrate Easter in the Sweetest Way
Easter is about joy, family, and little moments that make memories. Our handcrafted chocolate Easter eggs — buttercream, peanut butter, and coconut cream — bring that tradition to life in every bite.
Whether you’re shopping for kids, adults, or anyone in between, our chocolates make it easy to celebrate Easter beautifully. Each piece is crafted by hand, wrapped with care, and shipped nationwide — so you can share the taste of Philadelphia this holiday season.
Shop our complete Easter chocolate collection and celebrate spring the sweetest way possible — with Mueller Chocolate Co.
